Paul Aronson met Shalaine Foster on a website and had a dinner date with her twin sister, Shaina, according to court papers. When back at his E. 38th St. home, the pair tied him up and robbed him of his wallet and $470 in cash, authorities said Friday.
An 85-year-old wannabe sugar daddy who went on a web site seeking kinky companionship wound up with double trouble instead, the Daily News has learned.
The elderly Manhattan man was bound to a coffee table for 20 hours while the twin teenage vixens he had just wined and dined stole his credit cards and $470 in cash — and then went shopping for makeup, court papers revealed.
Shalaine Foster and her sister Shaina, both 17, were busted Monday and each was charged with kidnapping, robbery, burglary, larceny and assault.
The teens, who both have rap sheets, were ordered held without bail in Manhattan Criminal Court, records show.
Paul Aronson’s troubles began on Oct. 1 when he went on the www.seekingarrangement.com web site, which encourages users to “Find Your Sugar Baby.”
It features a bevy of babes from around the country with names like Diamond and Princess and lists their supposed ages and locations.
After taking a liking to Shaina, Aronson invited her to dinner, sources said. She showed up with Shalaine.
Hoping to move from fine dining to forbidden fruit, Aronson took the teens back to his E. 38th St. apartment, the sources said.
There — after a few cocktails — the twins pulled out zipties and relieved him of his dough, officials said.
Aronson called the cops after he was found — still bound but on the floor — by a friend, the sources said.
Outside the courtroom, a man who identified himself as their brother said “the story sounds f----d up.”
“But it’s also an 85-year-old wealthy man who basically has these young girls like they’re in a candy store,” he said. “We know he bought them liquor and intoxicated them and took him back to the house.”
A distressed-looking woman who said she was the girls’ mother, and who also declined to give her name, said she doesn’t believe the allegations.
“These are 17-year-old girls ... college-bound, upstanding citizens,” she said. “They’re not sleazy girls at all, whatsoever. It’s going to ruin their lives forever.”
“I don’t know what to say other than this is horrible,” she said.
Shaina has a 2013 felony arrest for possession of a sealed instrument, plus one sealed arrest, records show. Shalaine was arrested last April for introduction of prison contraband, plus two sealed arrests.
